When a small town sheriff and single mother learns that her daughter has been kidnapped by a serial killer that has just moved to town, she is forced to make a bargain to save her daughter's life. But, as people start to die, she realizes that in order to protect the good people in her town, she must pick the killer's victims, and bring them to him. She begins to choose victim after victim for him, and is drawn deeper into trouble when the FBI and the widow of one of the victims begin to investigate what is going on.